QUESTION: Can removal of amalgams cause high levels of lead in the body?
19 Nov 2005, Illinois USA
Can removal of amalgams cause high levels of lead in the body?
ANSWER: 19 Nov 2005
Further to the email from Nathan Jacobs, one of our other volunteer interns - Josephine Tesoriero - was kind enough to locate the following information regarding your question but due to the uncertainty of whether lead is released in sufficient quantities to raise the blood lead level during amalgam removal, I also put the question to the American Dental Association and ASOMAT (see emails below) who then referred me to the US equivalent and though I've waited a fair time for their response, I have not received a reply. So I hope you find all the info below useful and that it answers your question.
Of Web Research Carried Out By Josephine Tesoriero:
The removal of 'silver fillings' (i.e. amalgams) is conducted in order to prevent the long-term instance of harmful vapours leeching into the body. Amalgams consists of a mix of metals - generally 50% Mercury, 35% Silver, 15% Tin & other metals. Although lead was phased out as the primary source of metal used for fillings, modern amalgams made from mercury may still contain traces of lead- given that the principal sources of 'silver' are copper, copper-nickel, gold, lead and lead-zinc ores. It is therefore possible that alongside mercury, 'silver' amalgams may contain traces of lead, and that short-term exposure to its vapours are increased during the actual procedure of amalgam removal.
As stated in "Amalgam Fillings: Do Dental Patients Have a Right to Informed Consent?" by Michael A. Royal, http://law.unh.edu/risk/vol2/spring/royal.htm who quotes researcher and dentist with the University of Southern California School of Dentistry David Eggleston, the removal of fillings may temporarily raise the body's load of mercury in the blood. This is because the mercury vapor pressure doubles with every ten degree centigrade rise in temperature during the removal process. A description of the removal process is provided by Tuberose.com in an article on "Amalgam Fillings," which is accessible at the URL http://tuberose.com/Amalgam_Fillings.html. I would suspect that the same principle applies to lead, since removal would temporarily heighten the emission of the metal's poisonous vapours. I have reprinted important segments about amalgam removal for you below:
"If done properly, there is minimum exposure to increased levels of mercury
vapor caused by the removal procedure. The correct protocol requires the use
of high volumes of cold water both from the drill and separate irrigation by
the assistant, who should also be simultaneously using high volume suction
evacuation of the vapor and particles resulting from the removal procedure.
The assistant should hold the high-volume evacuator next to the tooth being
worked on until all of the cut filling and cavity have been cleaned out. It
is the volatility of mercury that necessitates all the precautions and
correct techniques. Mercury vapor pressure doubles with every ten degree
centigrade rise in temperature. One acceptable procedure that minimizes
extensive grinding involves sectioning the amalgam into chunks versus just
grinding it out.
Tips on how to minimise mercury exposure during the procedure are detailed
in section 4.2
Minimise Hg-exposure / absorption.
EMAIL FROM AMERICAN DENTAL ASSOCIATION: Wednesday, November 23
Subject: Can removal of amalgams cause high levels of lead in the body?
This is in response to your inquiry below. There is no indication that
removing amalgam fillings would cause lead to increase in the body.
EMAIL FROM ASOMAT (Australasian Society of Oral Medicine and Toxicology) Thursday, November 24, 2005
Subject: Re: Can removal of amalgams cause high levels of lead in the body?
I am unaware of any research which shows this. I would have thought that any detoxification of mercury would have also removed some of the lead as well. If the questioner is measuring hair levels of mercury and noticed that lead levels have increased in hair then that could well have been an indication that lead was in fact being excreted because the hair is an excretory organ and you would notice increased mercury levels also during the excretion process. There is no lead in amalgam fillings.
It might be worth an email to www.iaomt.net to just
confirm what i have
Us / Contact Us / Council
LEAD Project / egroups
/ Library / Fact Sheets / Home
Page / Media Releases
Last Updated 27 June 2012