|LEAD Action News vol 11 Number 2, December
2010, ISSN 1324-6011
Incorporating Lead Aware Times (ISSN 1440-4966) & Lead Advisory Service News (ISSN 1440-0561)
The journal of The LEAD (Lead Education and Abatement Design) Group Inc.
Guest Editor, Dr Chrissie Pickin. Editor-in-Chief: Anne Roberts
Synergism at Low Levels of Exposure?
By Rosalind Harrison, Toxicologist, Environmental Health
Humans are constantly exposed to a wide variety of man-made and naturally occurring chemicals simultaneously (Feron et al 1998, Sexton and Hattis 2007). This poses challenges to risk assessors because many different types of chemical mixtures can occur in the environment, and the hazards associated with such combined exposures may be different from when chemicals are considered individually (De Rosa et al 2004). Furthermore, there is an increasing awareness in the general population of simultaneous exposure to chemicals. Rosebery is a heavily mineralised area, and hence the Rosebery mine has operated continuously since 1936, with current potential beyond 2020. From the extensive environmental sampling program carried out by GHD consultants, in consultation with the mine operators, Minerals and Metals Group and the Environment Protection Authority, it is known that a number of metals exist in combination in the Rosebery environment.
Humans have always been exposed to metals, either through natural geological occurrence, resulting in contamination of food crops and drinking water, or through pollution from industrial and other human activities (Carpenter et al 2002, Lu and Kacew 2009). Some metals are essential to health, but may be toxic at high levels of exposure. Other metals have no known beneficial function, and long-term, high-level exposures may be harmful to health (Lu and Kacew 2009).
There are different ways in which chemicals can interact (ATSDR 2001, WHO 2009). Synergism comes from the Greek word ‘synergos’, meaning working together, and is one type of toxicological interaction. Synergism occurs when the effect caused by exposure to two or more chemicals at the same time is greater than the sum of the effects of the individual chemicals (CCOHS 2004). More simply, synergism is when a mixture of chemicals produces a stronger effect than could otherwise be predicted, i.e. more than additive, such as 1 plus 1 is greater than 2. Synergy is a public health concern because exposure to individual chemicals, which are considered to be safe, might pose unacceptable health risks when exposure occurs simultaneously to a combination of such chemicals. Therefore, the potential hazards of any chemical mixture need to be considered. Other types of interaction from exposure to mixtures can also occur; e.g. “additive” (when 1 plus 1 equals 2), or “protective” (when the presence of one substance reduces uptake of, or inhibits harm from another – e.g. zinc can reduce absorption of cadmium) (ATSDR 2001).
Synergistic interactions are known to occur in some situations. For example, there is a higher incidence of lung cancer resulting from simultaneous exposure to asbestos and tobacco smoke (through smoking), than would be expected from simple addition of the effects of asbestos and tobacco smoke acting independently (Erren et al 1999). However, synergistic effects such as this have only been shown to occur at high levels which are probably unrepresentative of the exposure levels present naturally in the environment. At relevant environmental exposures, i.e. low (non-toxic) doses, interactions between chemicals have not been shown to occur. Synergistic effects are typically only observed at high exposures – well above the toxicity threshold for each individual chemical; and it has been proposed that there is an interaction ‘threshold’, below which interactions in chemical mixtures are unlikely to be relevant (Feron et al 1998, Konemann and Pieters 1996, Yang and Dennison 2007).
The Department of Health and Human Services (DHHS) undertook to address concerns regarding the presence of metals in soil and groundwater in Rosebery and the possibility that these metals may be interacting synergistically. The DHHS has considered whether there is any evidence that synergistic interactions can occur following exposure to a range of metals in the environment, including whether adverse human health effects can occur despite normal biomonitoring data. Focussing on interactions associated with exposure to lead, arsenic, manganese, together with their potential interactions with other metals, the DHHS has concluded from the available evidence that interactions between metals have not been shown to occur at low levels of exposure for each individual metal (ATSDR 2004a, ATSDR 2004b, Choudhury and Mudipalli 2008, Wang and Fowler 2008). The understanding of the DHHS, supported by toxicologists who were consulted for advice, is that synergistic interactions and any resultant adverse health effects are associated only with high levels of exposure - at or above the individual toxicity threshold level for the metals concerned.
Overall, there is no evidence that low levels of exposure to mixtures of arsenic, lead and manganese in the Rosebery environment (based on the biomonitoring results) is resulting in synergistic interactions.
system lead poisoning |
LEAD Project | egroups | Library
- Fact Sheets | Home
Page | Media Releases
Newsletters | Q & A | Referral lists | Reports | Site Map | Slide Shows - Films | Subscription | Useful Links | Search this Site
Updated 24 January 2012